This page is an archive. The contents have been moved from another page for reference purposes only, and should be preserved in their current form. Discussion or voting on this page is not current. Any additions you make will probably not be read. The current version of this page can be found at VFD.
Delete. It's decently-written, but the humor seems to rely mostly on stale, cliche Fox News/"Obama is a Muslim"/"Republicans are scared racist old white men" jokes.--EpicWinner (talk) 21:40, October 19, 2015 (UTC)
See my comments below. The rules require nominator to search for a better copy in the History, and looking at the History, I believe the page would immediately get better if you would go back and pull out all the footnotes you added pointing the reader to proof of your position. Spıke🎙️21:58 19-Oct-15
Keep (2)
Keep. I like it. In my opinion, it is funny and its ridiculous portrayal of contemporary controversies is clever. I'm honestly surprised this is even being considered for deletion. —The preceding unsigned comment was added byAlec Pradeux (talk • contribs)
Keep. The narrative is good, the jokes are not the funniest or cleverest as the nominator says; it is by no means awful though. EStop⚓ 08:27, October 31, 2015 (UTC)
Comments
Abstain. As our Barack Obama is the result of deliberate work by the Colonizers, I have always been happy for our less accomplished writers to hack away at this other alternative. However, the footnote-heavy Intro sets the stage: This article will not make you laugh but is a battleground between pro-Obama and anti-Obama editors. The parts that direct readers away to other websites for evidence/proof are overt advocacy and should be removed. Other notorious flubs ("57 states") that conservatives use to prove that Obama is ignorant can easily be turned into fun jokes but should not be used to prove that Obama is ignorant; that's advocacy too. Spıke🎙️21:51 19-Oct-15
Hentai Girl
Score: 4 • voting closed
Delete (4)
Delete. and merge into hentai. Not outright terrible, but very stale, largely humorless article about an archetype in Internet pornography.--EpicWinner (talk) 21:43, October 25, 2015 (UTC)
Delete. In 2008 and 2009, Joe9320 and 007Reborn added soft porn, which Wikia of course swept away. In 2013, I rearranged what was left, which is: Not much. After scooping out any desired content, I'd redirect this title to my Magical girl. Spıke🎙️22:00 25-Oct-15
Delete. Simply awful. I've taken the few bits of desirable humor and merged it into hentai (as was suggested by EpicWinner). I don't like voting to delete articles, but there is no longer any point in having this article around. --Alec Pradeux (talk) 03:22, November 2, 2015 (UTC)
Keep (0)
No keep votes.
Comments
Deleted and replaced by a redirect to Hentai. Spıke🎙️03:43 2-Nov-15
Emo TV
Score: 0 • voting closed
Delete (1)
Delete. Do I really need to say it? Just more cruft with stale "emo cutting" jokes that we've seen a million times before.--EpicWinner (talk) 02:47, October 21, 2015 (UTC)
Keep (1)
Keep. Has potential for a really funny article this title. If no one else wants it, I'll add to my to-do list. EStop⚓ 08:17, November 5, 2015 (UTC)
Comments
Again, author e|m|c's original version was preferable to the testimonial ("So, you see") that was grafted onto it, though he too led off with a fart joke. The network's show "Finding Emo" shows that the emo theme built into a network could have been done well, and even stale "emo cutting" jokes could yield fun puns galore. Spıke🎙️03:10 21-Oct-15
Cartoon City
Score: 3 • voting closed
Delete (3)
Delete. An installment of the Wacky City genre. Humor is very random, article feels pointless.--EpicWinner (talk) 15:43, October 21, 2015 (UTC)
Delete (formerly Keep). I've twice tried to write a new Intro for this, but see that my concept has nothing to do with the existing article and would not wind up being called "Cartoon City." Spıke🎙️23:35 21-Oct-15
Delete. Had potential for enough comedy to keep if the author could draw it out. In present state, not worth keeping as it would not be looked up anyway. EStop⚓ 16:51, October 25, 2015 (UTC)
Keep (0)
Keep. A useful vehicle. "Cartoon City" only exists on Wikipedia as a "themed area" of Happy Valley Shenzhen, but there is also Toon Town and Sim City. Not to mention Video Village. In short, it could be about something (it almost already is about King of the Hill), and the creation of a New Town full of cartoon persons could have a better comedy strategy than A.R.S.E. Spıke🎙️16:32 21-Oct-15
Comments
Uncyclopedia:Dance like you've never danced before
Score: 5 • voting closed
Delete (5)
Delete. A photo scrapbook with no comedy writing that does not belong in the Uncyclopedia: namespace nor in any other content space. Spıke🎙️11:00 5-Nov-15
Delete. As above. EStop⚓ 13:52, November 6, 2015 (UTC)
Delete. Would that not be a valid reason to QVFD it? ConCass2 (talk) 17:56, November 6, 2015 (UTC)
Not for an article that has been on the site this long; hence the expression, "Wish we had gotten to this one quickly!" Spıke🎙️22:32 6-Nov-15
Delete. I don't see the point in having this around. Chunkles☎ talk✏️ contribs 19:50, November 7, 2015 (UTC)
Delete. Well, since it is now under my userspace, then there is no point in having it in this location anymore. Instead of abstaining, I will support your vote to delete. --Alec Pradeux (talk) 01:03, November 8, 2015 (UTC)
Keep (0)
Keep. I actually like it. This is one of those quirky Uncyclopedia "articles" which don't actually say anything, but are very amusing to find. I would abstain from this vote if I were allowed to keep the contents on my talk page. --Alec Pradeux (talk) 18:43, November 7, 2015 (UTC)
And what would you do with it? Spıke🎙️23:46 7-Nov-15
Comments
Michael Jefferson
Score: 5 • voting closed
Delete (5)
Delete. Random, crude, poorly-done humor and dodgy subject. Even looking at the older revisions of the article, there's not much worth saving.--EpicWinner (talk) 00:31, November 9, 2015 (UTC)
Delete. Let's misstate Michael Jackson's name in the page title, then misstate most of the facts and provide text whose only excellence is degree of recklessness as a rant. Indeed, all the awfulness was baked in by original author Un-The Thriller. Spıke🎙️00:44 9-Nov-15
Delete. Lifted directly from a South Park gag on Jackson (Jefferson) in a self-imposed witness protection program to protect him from being "framed" by the police. This is a very bad parody of a very good parody. EStop⚓ 07:12, November 9, 2015 (UTC)
Delete. As EStop said, this is just someone piggybacking off of a South Park episode - the lengthy intro quotes (barring Oscar Wilde) are all directly taken from the episode. As can be expected from anyone inexperienced being unoriginal, the writer here is unable to take satire from professional writers and succeed in doing so. ConCass2 (talk) 11:16, November 10, 2015 (UTC)
Delete. Blatant lack of originality. Cg097 (talk) 19:39, November 10, 2015 (UTC)
Keep (0)
No keep votes.
Comments
MySpace Perfection Groups
Score: 4 • voting closed
Delete (4)
Delete. Article written not to amuse anyone but to blog about the situation on some other website. (Who knew it still existed?) Spıke🎙️18:46 9-Nov-15
Delete. Looks like it's a literal description and not satire. Cg097 (talk) 19:39, November 10, 2015 (UTC)
Delete. A possible Wikipedia article that got deleted and then was re-posted over here. zzzzz. --RomArtus*Imperator ITRA (Orate) ® 13:01, November 12, 2015 (UTC)
Keep (0)
No keep votes.
Comments
Vatican City
Score: -3 • voting closed
Delete (0)
Delete. The Intro ("Vatican City is the headquarters of the Jewish Church of Latter Day Fakes.") warns the reader what he is in for: Solid Randumbo, lightly seasoned with rants against Western imperialism. Spıke🎙️12:30 8-Nov-15
Delete. An opportunity for some great satire missed. EStop⚓ 06:52, November 9, 2015 (UTC)
Delete. - ConCass2 (talk) 13:18, November 8, 2015 (UTC)
Keep (3)
Keep. Flip vote, treatment has commenced in earnest. Will be in too. EStop⚓ 12:38, November 13, 2015 (UTC)
Keep (formerly Delete). Not yet complete, but now contains large swaths of actual funny stuff. Spıke🎙️21:09 16-Nov-15
Rewritten by the admins. - ConCass2 (talk) 21:20, November 16, 2015 (UTC)
Comments
This title ought to stay and deserves our blessing (perhaps a collaboration). I'll happily add to the to-do list if no one else is feeling the Holy Spirit. EStop⚓ 06:52, November 9, 2015 (UTC)
Yes I can muck in this one. I know a lot about Da Popery. --RomArtus*Imperator ITRA (Orate) ® 19:55, November 10, 2015 (UTC)
Reclamation begun in place; jump in! Spıke🎙️00:58 11-Nov-15
Adminses
Score: 5 • voting closed
Delete (5)
We hates it, my precious. An article from 2006, when the most pressing business was framing the Admins as cult heroes. New Admin EStop objected to this fashion at Forum:Clear out of Administrator pages and I encouraged him to pare these pages down; but this one has no particular reason to exist at all. Spıke🎙️23:14 10-Nov-15
Delete. Devoid of humor, but to me the biggest sin is the title promising Gollum humor when there actually was none. A very short and disappointing read. Chunkles☎ talk✏️ contribs 19:42, November 11, 2015 (UTC)
Delete. Serves absolutely no purpose whatsoever. - ConCass2 (talk) 22:22, November 12, 2015 (UTC)
Delete. Flush. EStop⚓ 11:27, November 13, 2015 (UTC)
Keep (0)
No keep votes.
Comments
If you're looking for Gollum humor, we could always transcribe the recording. Cg097 (talk) 23:14, November 11, 2015 (UTC)
Fagrat
Score: 4 • voting closed
Delete (4)
Delete. Yes, this article from 2006 is about nothing more than a rat that is a faggot. Also: Awful formatting (I corrected the worst) and Oscar Wilde. Spıke🎙️02:39 12-Nov-15
Delete. Funny for rats perhaps but I don't think they can access uncyclopedia. --RomArtus*Imperator ITRA (Orate) ® 13:05, November 12, 2015 (UTC)
Delete. A mousy article that gets ratty with homosexuality... very cheesy. EStop⚓ 10:18, November 14, 2015 (UTC)
Keep (0)
No keep votes.
Comments
Bass guitar
Score: -2 • voting closed
Delete (0)
Delete. I started editing this to reword the intro, as the grammar was very bad. I realised the whole article is bad, so I was planning on rewriting it when I'm done with whatever else I'm writing, but I needed to consult the Council first. There is a decent edit here, but it's buried under a large amount of vandalism. - ConCass2 (talk) 14:21, November 14, 2015 (UTC)
Keep (2)
Keep. Boldfaced text in the rules at the top of this page state that nominator must look through the history for a decent edit. But this decent edit is still stubby, unillustrated, starts with boring truth, and ends with Pedo Humor. I see a way to develop this one, along the lines that a guitar with two fewer strings, like Volleyball, is just the thing for the punter who lacks the skill to do the "real thing." Spıke🎙️15:21 14-Nov-15
Did you put "Delete" in the keep box on purpose? - ConCass2 (talk) 17:00, November 14, 2015 (UTC)
No, force of habit; also, had not yet decided to rewrite it. Now corrected. Spıke🎙️17:11 14-Nov-15
Spike has rewritten the page, this ballot has served its purpose. - ConCass2 (talk) 17:00, November 14, 2015 (UTC)
Comments
I rewrote the intro on this one rather than userspacing it just yet. The rest of the article continues to ramble on about Cliff Burton, Geddy Lee and the DeLorean, and some other unfunny rants:
"Geddy Lee's mother,Mona Lisa,swallowed a compacted bass guitar,and 9 months later,Geddy was born with a bass in his hand and singing about Tom Sawyer and how he was a working man.He then taught a not even born Cliff Burton to play bass,saving the world from the homophobic time traveling 47 string guitarist-Jason Bourne-from destroying the world with his Marshall amp,as the world was not ready for the sound of Total Apocalyptiv Metal.As Cliff plugged in to his shoebox amp and his G-Bass Flux Capacitor in hand,given to him by Geddy,He was instantly defeated because Jason was too good for him. Bourne then played "(Anestesia) Pulling Teeth" with Cliff's bass and had sex with your mom To ensure that Leo Fender would be born,he then time traveled to the year 1983,where he PWn3d the fuck out of Ron McGovernment and Joined the group Metallica and then felt bad for beating cliff so he saved him again and let Burton replace him" - ConCass2 (talk) 15:39, November 14, 2015 (UTC)
Emo Grass
Score: 3 • voting closed
Delete (5)
Delete. Once again, mid-00s garden variety article where the author amuses themselves with the word "emo". "Professor de' Buttholeian Mc.GeeSauce 'on' RottenCheesyBread Emostein"...how is that supposed to be funny?--EpicWinner (talk) 02:43, October 21, 2015 (UTC)
Delete. Emo stuff is like an exhausted seam of humour. One Emo article is enough in my view. --RomArtus*Imperator ITRA (Orate) ® 10:30, November 5, 2015 (UTC)
Delete. "Emo grass cuts itself" is a good joke. But as Spike mentions below, this article - which doesn't manage to take the joke in any good direction - isn't worth keeping unless someone changes it. - ConCass2 (talk) 10:49, November 18, 2015 (UTC)
Keep. Potential, humorous. Those who dislike because it isn't funny need to realize that humor is subjective, and therefore personal opinion on humor should not be a valid reason to remove this article. Pecola1 (talk) 21:22, November 17, 2015 (UTC)
Comments
As stated, much potential. Also very funny, all votes against which claim it has bad humor clearly don't understand humor or have a bad taste. If the reason this should be deleted is because of bad humor, humor is subjective, so that reason should NOT stand. This type of article is what makes the UncyclopediA great, why remove the heart of it for a few people's personal preferences? Pecola1 (talk) 21:22, November 17, 2015 (UTC)
Once again, nominator is supposed to comb the history for a better version, and author Silophant's final 2007 edition omits much of the vandalism. Unfortunately, even in that version, Captain Obvious gives away the joke (a pretty clever one, in fact) on the article's first line, and the most memorable thing in the first screenful is author calling attention to the fact that he is writing in HTML--that is, he can't make his point without including stage direction. This one might be trivial to save. Spıke🎙️02:51 21-Oct-15
Emostein (pronounced: AHM-o-STEEN) is a pretty clear reference to Young Frankenstein. There's an element of humor, but it was stolen from another source. Cg097 (talk) 19:39, November 10, 2015 (UTC)
You know this Stein/Steen joke is derived from the unrelated American composers Elmer Bernstein and Leonard Bernstein. The former insisted he was BERN-steen and the other was BERN-stein but not unexpectedly, people would get it wrong. --RomArtus*Imperator ITRA (Orate) ® 13:32, November 12, 2015 (UTC)
The vote is deadlocked, but neither Keep voter talking about "potential" has shown us how, and I am reluctant to close the vote and return this page to forgetfulness. So, what have we got? "Have you heard about Emo Grass?" "No; what about Emo Grass?" "It cuts itself!" That is the entire comedy concept. You can try to stretch this in clever directions, but you ought not just use it as a springboard to randomness. The problem is that the page name depends on someone knowing the above joke; it is not anything in real life that someone would look up independent of this joke; if he does, he needs to get more for his effort than just the joke he already knows, plus some blather. That is the challenge before you. PS--Cg097, one can reference classic comedy without stealing it, if one does something original with it. Bass guitar steals the "double-neck bass" from Spinal Tap, but not just to re-tell their joke that the entire concept is absurd, but to feed my thesis that bassists are so bad that they never use frets. Spıke🎙️23:02 17-Nov-15
Enough. The joke is now told at the end of Emo. If anyone thinks the joke is not told enough, edit there. If anyone thinks we need the joke told at article length, re-create the page. I predict you will not need the former text to work from. Spıke🎙️13:42 20-Nov-15
Robbie Williams
Score: 5 • voting closed
Delete (5)
Delete. Endless barrage of insults towards an English singer who I have no idea what he did to offend the writer.--EpicWinner (talk) 22:07, November 16, 2015 (UTC)
Delete. A vast cesspool of gay-related profanities (I refused to use the term "gay jokes" because there's no humour there), vulgar insults and entirely random pop culture references (cameos by Lars Ulrich, Phil Anselmo, Eminem and Oprah) not to amuse the reader, but as EpicWinner accurately puts it, just to vent out the author's hatred of this Robbie Williams (whom I guess is a musician). - ConCass2 (talk) 22:41, November 16, 2015 (UTC)
Delete. We don't need an article on a borough of Luton, if no one can figure out how to take it beyond a litany of crude insults. Spıke🎙️17:23 12-Nov-15
Delete. Says nothing original. EStop⚓ 10:22, November 14, 2015 (UTC)
Delete. Pick any town in England (perhaps even Britain as a whole), and replace "Lewsey Farm" with that town, and the article would be exactly the same. Picking a place few people may look for makes it that much more useless. - ConCass2 (talk) 22:58, November 16, 2015 (UTC)
I'm sure that all 8,000 residents will be heartbroken. The previous edit was signed by PuppyOnTheRadio, but he is too lazy to create a signature yet. 08:56 am 23 Nov 2015
Delete. Another article found during the search through the Admin beatification pages highlighted by EStop. This one is another attempt to create a private club inside Uncyclopedia, with the title of Cunstable (Cunt, get it?). As EStop wrote in the Forum, it is hard enough getting newbies to follow a policy of writing funny stuff, without pages that look like policy but are not. Spıke🎙️18:31 13-Nov-15
Delete. The title seems interesting. But the article itself doesn't even look like it's attempting to joke (it probably is, it just sucks at doing so). - ConCass2 (talk) 10:15, November 14, 2015 (UTC)
Delete. Unfunny crude nonsense. EStop⚓ 10:27, November 14, 2015 (UTC)
Delete. Some more of the Ye Olde Crappe that escaped culling. Club it. --RomArtus*Imperator ITRA (Orate) ® 11:17, November 23, 2015 (UTC)
Keep (0)
No keep votes.
Comments
Uncyclopedia:Administrators
Score: 4 • voting closed
Delete (4)
Delete. This article is just a direct transfer of the lyrics of the Major-General's Song from the Pirates of Penzance. Not a good advert for encouraging comic creativity, or discouraging comic plagiarism. EStop⚓ 10:52, November 14, 2015 (UTC)
Delete. Nominator's Forum describes the problem and made me look at this yesterday. I did not see any beatification of fallen-away Admins, nor a point, nor any cleverness in the mechanical replacement in the Gilbert & Sullivan song. Spıke🎙️15:16 14-Nov-15
Long living page of nothing. The previous edit was signed by PuppyOnTheRadio, but he is too lazy to create a signature yet. 09:09 am 23 Nov 2015
Delete. Incredibly poorly-written and random, a relic from this site's 2005 era.--EpicWinner (talk) 00:59, November 15, 2015 (UTC)
Delete. After a relatively poor start, it went downhill. EStop⚓ 12:40, November 22, 2015 (UTC)
Keep (2)
Rewritten. For God's sake, she is just a mistreated black woman. Spıke🎙️12:19 23-Nov-15
Keep. Spike's been making Whoopi. EStop⚓ 16:46, November 23, 2015 (UTC)
Comments
Beavis and Butt-Head/example on wheels!
Score: 5 • voting closed
Delete (5)
Uh, this sucks. A sandbox for people who weren't funny enough to edit the mainspace article. Amateur attempts at imitating the characters, using cliche catchphrases they would say. See, the show is funny when it's animated and has professional voice actors reading the lines out - seeing it in plain text with ugly GIFs that look older than the show doesn't quite have the same effect. - ConCass2 (talk) 21:31, November 17, 2015 (UTC)
NANANANANANANANANANANANANANANA. I don't detect any original comedy writing but merely attempts to re-create the humor of the TV program. Not that I studied it in great detail. Spıke🎙️21:41 17-Nov-15
Thinking sucks, let’s go break something. EStop⚓ 20:05, November 19, 2015 (UTC)
Delete without reading. Anything on wheels is bad enough - even for those of us who get the reference. B&B are unimaginative humour, and even aping good humour is bad without starting from the bottom The previous edit was signed by PuppyOnTheRadio, but he is too lazy to create a signature yet. 10:12 pm 23 Nov 2015
Delete. More of a fan page (and a piss-poor example of that) than anything substantial. Clear the space. --RomArtus*Imperator ITRA (Orate) ® 09:09, November 24, 2015 (UTC)
Keep (0)
No keep votes.
Comments
WordGirl
Score: 5 • voting closed
Delete (5)
Delete. How to send up a PBS program with a female child star? Pedo Humor, naturally, from start to end. Kill this with big death. Spıke🎙️03:22 8-Aug-15
Pokemon rape humour in a different form. The previous edit was signed by PuppyOnTheRadio, but he is too lazy to create a signature yet. 10:21 pm 23 Nov 2015
Delete. Not funny.--EpicWinner (talk) 03:35, November 24, 2015 (UTC)
Delete. Per Spike and PuppyOnTheRadio. Cg097 (talk) 07:08, November 24, 2015 (UTC)
I originally nominated this 03:22, August 8, 2015 (UTC).TotalCuddles02 edited VFD to nominate a page, by editing my nomination. Lost since then. Dope! Spıke🎙️04:16 23-Nov-15
Delete. Randumbo.--EpicWinner (talk) 22:30, November 24, 2015 (UTC)
Delete. Mixing up Babar (the Elephant) with Representative Bob Barr was brilliant. Too bad "Stephen Colbert" spilled the beans in an initial quotation and the author never came back to it, or anything else, past the Intro. I would like to write what this article wanted to be, but I won't be needing anything that is here. Spıke🎙️03:42 25-Nov-15
Delete. This article begins with a factual (but outdated, so I assume the article is more than two years old) statement about the vocalist, then a section on his band, where the author intentionally confuses them with Guns 'n' Roses and then Pearl Jam (while the former makes no sense, the latter is satirical and quite witty, but the joke is overdone afterwards). Finally, the article completely devolves into a load of nonsense I can't possibly fathom. It's safe to say, "this article is going to alienate a lot of fans of STP". - ConCass2 (talk) 11:08, November 11, 2015 (UTC)
Delete. Needs cleaning up or as ConCass2 says, a re-hash and transfer to the Stone Temple Pilots article. EStop⚓ 10:05, November 14, 2015 (UTC)
Meh The previous edit was signed by PuppyOnTheRadio, but he is too lazy to create a signature yet. 08:36 am 23 Nov 2015
Keep (0)
No keep votes.
Comments
Formerly Keep. No photos, but after I deleted two of its dead-end sections, the article does seem to try to be doing something: Link song titles and lyrics to Weiland's drug habit. That an article might alienate fans is not a criterion for deletion; cracking wise with any star evokes rage from some fans. Nominator please Rehab this. Spıke🎙️13:55 11-Nov-15
My "alienate a lot of fans" line wasn't a serious criteria, it was just a joking reference to how the article uses the line repeatedly. Personally I believe the "linking song titles and lyrics to drug habits" could be done at the better article Stone Temple Pilots (which could really do with a serious brush-up on its writing) - this one just seems to ramble on incoherently. - ConCass2 (talk) 14:24, November 11, 2015 (UTC)
Ah, Led Zeppelin, right? I'll strike my Keep vote, but still think the article is better repaired than deleted. Spıke🎙️14:49 11-Nov-15
I wouldn't know anything about Led Zeppelin so I'm not sure what you're referring to there. I'd prefer redirecting the link to "Scott Weiland" to the main STP article and then improving that, so we can have one good article rather than two decent ones. - ConCass2 (talk) 15:00, November 11, 2015 (UTC)
This is when the 'age issue' kicks in for us 'oldies' on the site. Communication Breakdown. --RomArtus*Imperator ITRA (Orate) ® 13:07, November 12, 2015 (UTC)
Page is now redirected to Stone Temple Pilots. Prior text is still in the page history if anyone needs it. Spıke🎙️21:10 26-Nov-15
Pirate king
Score: 5 • voting closed
Delete (5)
Delete. Wikipedia has WP:Pirate King, a disambiguation page to three things. Our article seems to be about none of these three things. In fact, it is not about anything, a bit of fan-fiction Randumbo about coronations (with vague references to the US Electoral College) and fighting. Spıke🎙️01:19 21-Nov-15
Delete. Keel-haul. EStop⚓ 12:35, November 22, 2015 (UTC)
I hear the weeping of both Gilbert and Sullivan. The previous edit was signed by PuppyOnTheRadio, but he is too lazy to create a signature yet. 10:18 pm 23 Nov 2015
Delete. And here's the 5th vote to put it out of its misery. - ConCass2 (talk) 18:08, November 27, 2015 (UTC)
Keep (0)
No keep votes.
Comments
HowTo:Be Super Duper Annoying
Score: 5 • voting closed
Delete (5)
Delete. 100% tediously long list; 100% Prankster Humor. Spıke🎙️22:33 14-Nov-15
Delete. Terrible. EStop⚓ 15:22, November 19, 2015 (UTC)
My previous comments still stand. The previous edit was signed by PuppyOnTheRadio, but he is too lazy to create a signature yet. 09:30 pm 23 Nov 2015
Delete. Considering we have a page that mentions the sins of 'listing' - how did this escape so long from destruction?? —The preceding unsigned comment was added byRomartus (talk • contribs)
Delete. Article demonstrating how to be annoying is in fact annoying. ConCass2 (talk) 22:02, November 28, 2015 (UTC)
Keep (0)
No keep votes.
Comments
I failed to apply {{VFD}}; clock reset after 8 days. Spıke🎙️04:21 23-Nov-15
Delete. Not English. Not topical. Not funny. Since 2006. Spıke🎙️14:21 15-Nov-15
Delete. I remember facing the Cyberdemon on the Tower of Babel back in the day. For those that may not know, all that (Deimos, E2M8, Cyberdemon) is a reference to popular video game Doom. Now, someone taking a biblical concept and mixing it with a video game would be funny. Unfortunately, the author utterly fails at making any decent humour out of that reference. - ConCass2 (talk) 14:31, November 15, 2015 (UTC)
Now, that sounds like an actual comedy concept. Yours to save. Spıke🎙️14:37 15-Nov-15
If I were to save this article, it'd have to wait until I'm done with other articles I'm working on. - ConCass2 (talk) 14:47, November 15, 2015 (UTC)
Delete... from the mainspace, perhaps it could be userspaced for later if it has potential? EStop⚓ 15:34, November 19, 2015 (UTC)
Even conceptually I'm not a fan. Mixing biblical references and popular culture is a hard stretch even when there are numerous relationships between them (like Isaac The Tank Engine). I don't recall a Tower of Babel reference in Doom, especially given the original came out roughly 2 decades ago, and has as much relevance now as Pong did back then. An article on the biblical story of Babel could work - especially given the undertones if a father figure destroying a phallic symbol out of jealousy - but this is far from that. NRV. (For No Redeeming Value, not the bible translation New Revised Edition.) The previous edit was signed by PuppyOnTheRadio, but he is too lazy to create a signature yet. 09:53 pm 23 Nov 2015
Given that the Tower of Babel story is over 3000 years old, that something is too old to be "relevant" isn't a fair criticism. On that note, as Doom is a high-profile series with a new instalment being released, youngsters may be introduced to it and if they are already on Uncyc and read an article mentioning it, they would get such a reference. Of course, that's only if it's done well. - ConCass2 (talk) 21:31, November 26, 2015 (UTC)
I think you should deal with this criticism simply by taking special care to spell things out so that your replacement concept appeals even to readers who didn't play the 20-year-old game. Anything can be mixed with anything else. Spıke🎙️11:23 27-Nov-15
Keep (2)
Keep (formerly Delete). Rewritten. I got rid of the video-game hook, but if you can do it well, feel free to add it back in. PS--Now put back in, along with even one of the original jokes. Spıke🎙️12:54, 23:36 27-Nov-15
Keep. With Spike having replaced the original "nobody cares" hook with genuine Biblical jokes, the article is safe to stay. ConCass2 (talk) 11:49, November 29, 2015 (UTC)
Delete. It's decently-written, but the humor seems to rely mostly on stale, cliche Fox News/"Obama is a Muslim"/"Republicans are scared racist old white men" jokes.--
Keep. I like it. In my opinion, it is funny and its ridiculous portrayal of contemporary controversies is clever. I'm honestly surprised this is even being considered for deletion. —The preceding 
Abstain. As our 