Uncyclopedia:Votes for deletion/Archive-2016-10

From Uncyclopedia, the content-free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search

This page is an archive. The contents have been moved from another page for reference purposes only, and should be preserved in their current form. Discussion or voting on this page is not current. Any additions you make will probably not be read. The current version of this page can be found at VFD.

Hilary Duff

Score: 1 • voting closed
Delete (1)
  1. Symbol delete vote.svg Delete. This is absolutely terrible. There's very little humor, mostly just a barrage of insults, and the article doesn't cover her career thoroughly.--HolUp (talk) 00:24, August 19, 2016 (UTC)
Keep (0)

No keep votes.

Comments
  • Nominator and I have cleaned it up a little. I like the way it starts in Valleygirlese, but the body of the article has no comedy strategy at all except the trite one of casting her as a slut. (And a Nazi?) Spıke 🎙️00:51 19-Aug-16

Angry Asian Kid

Score: 0 • voting closed
Delete (1)
  1. Symbol delete vote.svg Delete. Dreary. Reads like a bad voice over to kids film and not an Uncyclopedia article. small   SIR  MAC  BOSWELL  Mac Boswell's user page   [†]   22:43, August 22, 2016 (UTC)
Keep (1)
  1. Symbol keep vote.svg Keep. This page has been here before and what you are reading is my rewrite. The joke is that the "anger" attributed to the Asian Kid is entirely in the mind of his beholder. Can this be made clearer? Spıke 🎙️00:52 23-Aug-16
Comments
  • Added {{VFD}} and reset time. Expert 3222 07:24, September 10, 2016 (UTC)

iCarly

Score: 0 • voting closed
Delete (1)
  1. Symbol delete vote.svg Delete. Not funny, relies on a painfully stupid in-joke that a teen sitcom is worse than Satan.--HolUp (talk) 05:17, August 23, 2016 (UTC)
Keep (1)
  1. Symbol keep vote.svg Keep. The article was originally part of Hyperbole's story arc to develop his one-man website meme about Miranda Cosgrove being impregnated by a newt and relied on bickering narrators. Abacab333 did one of his gut-and-paste operations that rendered it cleaner. Nominator has undone this clean-up. Spıke 🎙️11:55 23-Aug-16
Comments

Gilbert Gottfried

Score: 0 • voting closed
Delete (1)
  1. Symbol delete vote.svg Delete. This is dreadful and full of randumbo.--HolUp (talk) 04:55, August 28, 2016 (UTC)
Keep (1)
  1. Sorry, this is a real article about a real subject and even, at the start, has a real comedy strategy: "The guy has a really irritating voice" that the article describes enjoyably. That it then descends into Randumbo and ultimately Chuck Norris means it is not feature-worthy, not that it should be expunged from the site altogether. Spıke 🎙️00:52 29-Aug-16
Comments
  • Nominator and I cleaned this up. The subject is on Wikipedia, but I don't know why the voice actor of cartoon shows is notable except to extreme insiders. Spıke 🎙️00:06 29-Aug-16
    He's also known for stand-up routines on Howard Stern and SNL.--HolUp (talk) 00:18, August 29, 2016 (UTC)
    Very well, but you have now gone beyond "cleaning it up" to complete disembowelment. You should add humor and book the Save, or at least restore everything but the listcruft so voters can decide how dreadful it was. Spıke 🎙️00:28 29-Aug-16

Miranda Cosgrove's Uterus

Score: 0 • voting closed
Delete (1)
  1. Symbol delete vote.svg Delete. Relies solely Hyperbole's navelism in-joke. All good comedy is based somewhat in reality (or exaggeration of reality); this has nothing to do with Cosgrove, it's random sex humor.--HolUp (talk) 22:48, August 28, 2016 (UTC)
Keep (1)
  1. Symbol keep vote.svg Keep. I don't want knock-off articles, as iCarly started out being, in which case the "basis in reality" was nothing but this wanna-be meme. But we ought to keep the original. Spıke 🎙️00:04 29-Aug-16
Comments

Encyclopedia Dramatica

Score: -1 • voting closed
Delete (1)
  1. Symbol delete vote.svg Delete. Poorly written navelism. Delete this article and have Encyclopædia Dramatica (Encyclopædia) replace it.--HolUp (talk) 01:51, September 18, 2016 (UTC)
Keep (2)
  1. Symbol keep vote.svg Keep. This is a disambiguation page. It points to two Featured Articles on ED (which presumably aren't going anywhere), a mediocre HowTo: referencing ED, and Goa Tse, which I guess is supposed to be humor value-added. Given that we have multiple ED articles, a disambig is appropriate, and this one does all a disambig has to do, though it might be better with a photo. I don't sense any navelism. Spıke 🎙️02:44 18-Sep-16
  2. Symbol keep vote.svg Keep. I assume the nominator meant Encyclopedia Dramatica (Website) (he has added VFD template there). Expert 3222 13:14, September 30, 2016 (UTC)
    I agree and have invited nominator to open a new ballot on it. It is not a Featured Article as I stated above. Spıke 🎙️14:05 30-Sep-16
Comments

Worst 100 Ways to Win an Argument‎

Score: 5 • voting closed
Delete (5)
  1. Symbol delete vote.svg Delete. A repulsive chaw of listcruft. Spıke 🎙️04:16 23-Sep-16
  2. Symbol delete vote.svg Delete. Very listy and a bit rapey. Irritable of contents (talk) 16:14, September 24, 2016 (UTC)
  3. Symbol delete vote.svg Delete. An oul list filled with utter crap. TheWikiMan026 (talk) 18:36, September 27, 2016 (UTC)
  4. Symbol delete vote.svg Delete. Some entries are interesting, but most are just awful. Expert 3222 13:08, September 30, 2016 (UTC)
  5. Symbol delete vote.svg Userspace The sections need to be organized further, and an intro written to each section, with the duplicate entries removed. This will probably take longer than a week, so I am moving this to my userspace for further work. -- Simsilikesims(♀GUN) Talk here. 03:55, October 19, 2016 (UTC)
Keep (0)

No keep votes.

Comments

Giant

Score: 5 • voting closed
Delete (5)
  1. Symbol delete vote.svg Delete. Starts with a bland caption to a photo of Robert Wadlow, followed by another bland caption of Andre The Giant from an image titled Andre the giant before the rape. Criikey, mate! relies on nationalities swearing and random. Also only covers giant men and not as much as a giant ant or giant woman. I'm not really sure Jack and the Bean Stalk, Gulliver's Travels, or Kaiju movie references would make for very long or good replacements either, though admittedly every other major fantasy creature has a page. Irritable of contents (talk) 16:14, September 24, 2016 (UTC)
  2. Symbol delete vote.svg Delete. A short, unclever anti-capitalist rant despite the brief digression in the Intro to anti-gay rant. Spıke 🎙️16:22 24-Sep-16
  3. Symbol delete vote.svg Delete. Near enough a list. Of shit, that is. TheWikiMan026 (talk) 18:35, September 27, 2016 (UTC)
  4. Symbol delete vote.svg Delete. Nix this in the nadgers. --Laurels.gifRomArtus*Imperator ITRA (Orate) ® 20:03, October 2, 2016 (UTC)
  5. Symbol delete vote.svg Delete. Belittling.  EStop Press here for Room Service⚓ 23:17, October 10, 2016 (UTC)
Keep (0)

No keep votes.

Comments

King of the Hill

Score: 4 • voting closed
Delete (4)
  1. Symbol delete vote.svg Delete. Mostly random nonsense that doesn't have much to do with the show at all. ConCass2 (talk) 08:05, September 2, 2016 (UTC)
  2. Symbol delete vote.svg Delete. From the Intro on, the only strategy is to combine random and untrue assertions uncleverly. Then it descends into a potentially infinite list of spin-offs. Spıke 🎙️15:14 2-Sep-16
  3. Symbol delete vote.svg Delete.  EStop Press here for Room Service⚓ 03:33, October 3, 2016 (UTC)
  4. Symbol delete vote.svg Delete. Randumbo. --Laurels.gifRomArtus*Imperator ITRA (Orate) ® 22:17, October 13, 2016 (UTC)
Keep (0)

No keep votes.

Comments

Saw: The Animated Series

Score: 4 • voting closed
Delete (4)
  1. Symbol delete vote.svg Delete. This is a hilarious concept for a one liner reference, like it is on the Scooby Doo page, in much the way the clone wars sounds like a cool idea; however it ends up executed badly. It's mostly a repetitive list of rather random episodes; fox retards shows up three times. I suppose this could be like Harvey Birdman but with torture but even that sounds like beating a dead horse 26 times mixed with rule 34. Irritable of contents (talk) 01:33, September 10, 2016 (UTC)
  2. Symbol delete vote.svg Delete. Intro virtually screams, "I am going to bang out a dumb article about a nonexistent TV knock-off of a famous movie. How dumb? "The first episode...drew 10,500,82 viewers." The more clear it is that I just dashed this off, the more you will laugh, right? Later, author doesn't read UN:LIST, which explains that the problems with endless uncreative lists stay the same if you format them as Wikitables. Spıke 🎙️03:51 10-Sep-16
  3. Symbol delete vote.svg Delete.  EStop Press here for Room Service⚓ 06:48, September 21, 2016 (UTC)
  4. Symbol delete vote.svg Delete. Sawdust. --Laurels.gifRomArtus*Imperator ITRA (Orate) ® 18:01, October 2, 2016 (UTC)
Keep (0)

No keep votes.

Comments
Retrieved from "https://uncyclopedia.com/w/index.php?title=Uncyclopedia:Votes_for_deletion/Archive-2016-10&oldid=5962930"