Uncyclopedia:Pee Review/Intelligent Math
Intelligent Math[edit]
Still not signed in. This has earned me a doctorate, so I'm rather happy with it so far. Now I want it to be a feature. Pup
- Signed in all proper like now.Pup
- Well, as I've had a bit of college math and more than my share of Intelligent Design....I'll check your equations in 4.8992 hours. WHY???PuppyOnTheRadio 07:17, November 26, 2009 (UTC)
Introduction to your reviewer
Yeah, I think you know something about what I've done here, so will skip that part. In regard to the topic of your article, I'm not a math expert but do know my way around a quadratic equation, and am pretty familiar with Intelligent Design/Creationism, Evolution, and know why a banana and peanut butter are not each an atheist's nightmare. Also did you see the mention of "Intelligent Math" here? | ||
Concept: | 9 | What can I say? I love the concept. |
Prose and Formatting: | 7.5 | As you may know, I put Humour in with Prose and Formatting to avoid repeating myself, but do score them separately. And remember, strikeout means I'd suggest you cut it out, and if it's followed by something in paranthesis, that's something I suggest be added.
I like your prose and the way you set this up. It actually holds up better than most of the Intelligent Design/Creationism things I've heard and seen. You have some "solid" arguments (if, of course, the reader accepts the assumptions) such as God is infinite and has infinite power thus infinite mass and size, and then some silly arguments like dropping a leaking cup. I like the combination, as it fits what I've seen--every once in a while I run into an argument against Evolution that I actually have to stop and think about, but not too often. I think your formatting is great--you've put in a lot of stuff that ordinarily would be difficult to make work together. Your score would be higher if it weren't for a number of grammar problems, which I describe below. Your introduction
Foundations
Understanding π
The shape of the world
The size of the universe
Scripture quotes
Optional, but many Christian sources follow the practice of the King James Version, and always capitalize God's pronoun. "And then He created the universe...and He made man in His own image," etc. |
Humo(u)r: | 6 | The humour here is subtle, which actually I think is good. The main problem I see is actually with the Prose--when I have to read something over again to get the joke, it doesn't usually seem funny. With some rewording this score would be higher. I don't find this a "laughing out loud ha ha," and again much of it is actually better (and thus less funny) than some of the real arguments (see the banana and peanut butter links above, if you haven't already). But I think someone who has a concept of what you're pulling here will, with rewriting as suggested above, find this very amusing. (With fixes, I would probably give Humour an 8). |
Images: | 8 | I like your images and captions. I do have a little problem with the first one, with the ape at the chalk board. The title and the author's name look like they were just "tacked on." In other words, they don't look like what I'd expect to see on a book cover, especially the author's name. I might also want an explanation why the Intelligent Mathematics guy would want an ape on the cover--some explanation might be nice. |
Miscellaneous: | 8.75 | Average of above |
Final Score: | 39.25 | I think with a little work, this could be what I'd find a very good article. (And you notice the score as is? For me in my current thinking, when I rate 40 it means I'm thinking about VFH). |
Reviewer: | WHY???PuppyOnTheRadio 18:25, November 26, 2009 (UTC) |