Talk:Jebediah Guthrie
| This article was nominated for deletion on May 27, 2021.
The result of the discussion was Revised, Kept.
|
|||
2021 VFD conversation[edit]
- Originally at User talk:Dark Web, White Hat, following a deletion discussion nominated by Dark Web, White Hat.
Sorry to vote against you. This is precious. If you would bring over a suitable photo, I think we're done. Spıke 🎙️11:02 25-May-21
- No, it's fine. So long as somebody gets something out of it, it's good. Will do. (talk) 01:09, 26 May 2021 (UTC)
I think this second photo takes it too far. That Jebediah has/had super powers is not the point of this article, but rather, simply, "Wow, he looks just like me, literally." Especially given that the first photo does seem to show his lazors preparing to fire. I would rather this article showcase author's two paragraphs, such as they are, than try to do a complete job of it. Spıke 🎙️02:48 26-May-21
- Okay. Shall I delete the image then? No strong feelings either way. (talk) 02:50, 26 May 2021 (UTC)
I delete orphaned photos and sometimes catch hell for it. Or maybe move this conversation to Talk:Jebediah Guthrie (as I did to Talk:Flamethrower) and use the photo to illustrate the talk page, by way of warehousing it.
My reason for moving stuff to the article talk page is that someone might want to research the development of the article, and it would be more tedious having to scan the authors' talk pages (especially if they had been archived) (hint hint). Spıke 🎙️03:14 26-May-21
As the article was named Jedediah Guthrie (Marvel) before Dark Web corrected it in bringing it to VFD, I wonder if creator's entire point, that the comic character is a namesake of him, is in error! Spıke 🎙️17:53 27-May-21